(Cross-posted to
my other journal over here)
We're expecting our first kid in about five and a half months (gulp) and since I'm at a point where moving around and doing things doesn't actually make me exhausted or sick at the moment, I decided to take advantage of it and start going through our bookshelves to purge them. (I know I have plenty of time until the kid can read but I just don't see myself having the energy/motivation/time in the next couple of years, haha. I might as well strike now while the iron is hot!)
I'm not a fan of organizational or academic or governmental censorship at all, but I'm a huge believer in parental censorship. What I mean by that is that I want to have plenty of books on hand, so that if the kid ever wants something to read they can just grab something off the shelf and go to town. I want to have a wide variety of books, too, so that there will always be something to interest them and so that they can serendipitously find good things to read whenever they want it. I also want to make sure that there aren't books on the shelf that I would be concerned if they grabbed and started reading. There are some books we own that really are only appropriate for late teens/adults, and I don't want my eight year old or whatever grabbing it before they're ready.
This is kind of a personal issue for me in some ways. I read *a ton* when I was younger, but I didn't have a lot of reading guidance that I can recall. (Well, I do remember in second grade being really irked because the librarian wouldn't let me into the section of the library where the third and fourth graders could go. I was way beyond Berenstein Bears at that point and had ready every one of them anyway, and I was bored with the "baby" books that were in our section. I was reading the books my sister brought home by then and she would have been in fifth grade. So. Annoying.)
As far as at home, I think my parents really trusted us to know what was good and what wasn't, and figured that more or less whatever we were reading was fine. And it's true, I wasn't pulling out like adult romances or anything weird like that. No
Lady Chatterly's Lover or anything. I'm pretty sure Mom had to approve whatever we got out of the library, and that she would have complained if there was anything wildly inappropriate. But what I did get into was horror, and at a very young age. I was reading Stephen King and Dean Koontz when I was eight or so, and that was too young for one reason: I have a super active imagination. I *should not* have been reading terrifying books like that at that age. Heck, I still can't really handle them at this age, not unless I read them really early in the morning and then watch cartoons or something before bedtime. (Confession: sometimes I still have nightmares of the clown from
It, just watching me. *shivers*)
Anyway. That's the kind of thing I want to prevent for my kid. If they're an advanced reader they'll want to read whatever I have on the shelves, but if they're of a sensitive nature or super overactive imagination there are things that they just shouldn't read even though they'll be able to read them, and possibly want to read them. (No one forced me to read Pet Cemetery, folks. That was all me.) I want to be able to give them reading freedom while guiding their choices: give them a broad category to look through, but narrow that category to things that are appropriate and that they're ready for. I'm all about letting the kid have challenging books. I know the benefits of challenging reading -- I know a lot of my vocabulary and random interesting knowledge comes because I've been a voracious reader my whole life, and didn't just stick to the books that were recommended for my age group. But I also know that a lot of my nightmare fuel, a lot of my sleepless nights throughout my life, have been because I was reading things I just was not ready for.
It's an interesting thing, though, making decisions about the bookshelves before I even know what this kid is like. There are obvious things to take away -- sorry, baby, but you're not reading
V for Vendetta for a loooong time -- and there are obvious things to leave. But what about stuff like, say,
Fat Kid Rules the World, which is a fantastic fantastic book for teens but is wholly inappropriate (language and drug use) for younger ages, in my opinion. I don't want to have to play revolving bookshelves every five years. I want there to be two piles - the books in the attic, and the books on the shelves. So what do I do with
Fat Kid?
I'm thinking about sorting out the bookshelves by age level. Like, the one low-to-the-ground bookshelf will be the picture albums/picture books/grade school lit. Then maybe another one will be the rest of the grade school lit plus teen lit. Then maybe the rest will be our non-fiction and "grownup" books like Stephen R. Donaldson, Brandon Sanderson, Tolkien, Shakespeare, Cervantes, Dante, etc. (For the record, I think a lot of the "grownup" books are totally fine for a kid to pick up. I wouldn't worry if my kid was ten and reading
Mistborn. Those are awesome books with very little for me to worry about.)
Sorry about the rambling! This is something I've been thinking about for awhile and now that I'm finally getting down to working on some of it today, I realize that it is not as easy as I thought it would be! Expect a few more entries about this while I work around all the interesting issues I'm running into. (Plus, you know, my husband and I have over 700 books in our collection and we just can't stop buying more, so this is not a one-day project.)
Thoughts? Suggestions? Am I crazy for doing this?